Jamal Walidi on the nation and the role of Islam in shaping Tatar identity
https://doi.org/10.31162/2618-9569-2025-18-2-287-302
Abstract
The article is devoted to the analysis of the views and arguments of the Tatar scientist Jamal Walidi (Validi) on the problems of national identity. In the scientifi c literature, J. Walidi is better known as a literary critic and linguist. However, the scientifi c legacy of the researcher included socio-philosophical studies on complex issues of “nation-building” and national identity. These almost “forgotten” articles and a separate work “Millat wa millyat” (Nation and national) are considered to be the best studies on this issue among the scientists of their time. His writings undoubtedly demonstrate that J. Walidi was a theorist and an original thinker. Currently, the appeal to the forgotten legacy of the past and the study of the problem of national identity is becoming relevant, since this topic remains relevant to the public, and, moreover, it requires a new modern view and analysis.
The subject of our research is the history of Tatar national identity, the object of study is the works of J. Walidi on this issue.
The goal is to show the contribution by J. Walidi into the study of the problems of national identity in Tatar historiography.
The article describes the history of the formation and development of the problems of self-identification and the study of identity issues. Scientific activity of J. Walidi, his views and arguments are revealed in the context of similar studies by other scientists and thinkers of the early 20th century. The author also emphasizes such important issues as the naming of the ethnonym, the meaning of the concepts “nation” and “national”, and the fundamental factors of the nation in the vision of the scientist J. Walidi.
About the Author
E. K. SalakhovaRussian Federation
lmira K. Salakhova, Cand. Sc. (History), Senior Research Fellow
Department of New History
Kazan
References
1. Tatary [Tatars]. Мoscow: Nauka Press; 2001. 583 p. (In Russian)
2. Mardzhani Sh. Poleznye vesti o sostoyanii Kazani i Bulgara (Mustafad al-akhbar fiakhvali Kazan va Bulgar) [The useful news about the state of Kazan and Bulgaria (Mustafad al-akhbar fiahwal Qazan wa Bulghar)]. P. 1. Kazan: Magarif-Vakyt Press; 2022. 216 p. (In Russian)
3. Millätne nichek anlisiz [How do you understand the nation]. Аn. 1913;22:394. (In Tatar)
4. Salakhova E.K. 20 gasyr bashynda tatar khatyn-kyzlary küzlegennän millät problemalary [The problem of Tatar national identity at the beginning of the 20<sup>th</sup> century through the prism of a woman’s view]. Istoricheskaya etnologiya [Historical Ethnology]. 2024;1:17–29. DOI: 10.22378/he.2024-9-1-17-29. (In Tatar)
5. Shakurov F. “Törek ugly” kem ul? [Who is the “son of the Turk”?] Gasyrlar avazy echo vekov [Echo of centuries]. 2000;1/2:260–261. (In Tatar)
6. ‘Aziz ‘U. Millätne nichek tä‘rif qilirgha? [How to defi ne a nation]. Аn. 1913;8:137–138. (In Tatar)
7. ‘Aziz ‘U. Millätne nichek anlisiz [How do you understand the nation] Аn. 1913;1913;22:395–398; 23:407–410; 24:431–433. (In Tatar)
8. ‘Aziz ‘U. Törekme, tatarmi? [Turk or Tatar?]. Kazan: Qoriltay Press; 1918. 11 p. (In Tatar)
9. ‘Ubäydullin ‘A. Millätcheleknen bä‘dhe äsaslari [Other foundations of the nation]. Kazan: Conscience Press; 1918. 30 p. (In Tatar)
10. Walidi J. Millät wä Milliyät [Nation and national]. Orenburg: Waqt Press; 1914. 50 p. (In Tatar)
11. Islam v Srednem Povolzht: istoriya I sovremennost. Ocherki [Islam in the Middle Volga region: history and modernity. The essays]. Mukhametshin R.M. (sc. ed.). Kazan: Master Layn Press; 2001. 516 p. (In Russian)
12. Jamal Walidi: ädäbi kham tarikhi-dokumental jyentyk [Jamal Walidi: literary and historical-documentary collection]. Kazan: Jyen Press; 2010. 624 p. (In Tatar)
13. Walidi J. Kawem wä kabilämez arasinda [Between the clan and the people]. Shura. 1912; 1: 8-12. (In Tatar)
14. Izmajlov I.L. Natsiya [The Nation]. [Electronic source]. Available at: https://tatarica.org/ru/razdely/narody/naciya (Accessed 10/03/2025). (In Russian)
15. Salakhova E.K. G. Gobäydullin khezmätlärendä “khalyk”, “millät” töshenchäläre [The concepts of “People”, “Nation” in the works of G. Gubaydullin]. Istoricheskaya etnologiya [Historical Ethnology]. 2022;3:457–467. (In Tatar)
16. Mukhametshin R. Islam v obshchestvennoy I politicheskoy zhizni tatar I Tatarstana v XX veke [Islam in the social and political life of the Tatars and Tatarstan in the 20<sup>th</sup> century]. Kazan: Tatar Book Publishing House; 2008. 246 p. (In Russian)
17. Ocherki istorii tatarskoy obshchestvennoy mysli [Essays on the history of Tatar social thought]. Amirkhanov R.M. (scientific editor). Kazan: Tatar Book Publishing House; 2000. 191 p. (In Russian)
Review
For citations:
Salakhova E.K. Jamal Walidi on the nation and the role of Islam in shaping Tatar identity. Minbar. Islamic Studies. 2025;18(2):287-302. (In Russ.) https://doi.org/10.31162/2618-9569-2025-18-2-287-302